When to Choose Custom Millwork – A.F. Johnson Millwork
- Uncategorized
Choosing between custom and modular millwork depends on how a space will be used, how often the design must be repeated, and how strongly the environment should represent the brand. In a recent episode of The Maker’s Intent, host Mike Downer speaks with Kyle Greenfield, president of A.F. Johnson Millwork, about when should a business choose custom millwork, when modular systems work better, and why long-term value matters more than price alone.
The key takeaway is straightforward: modular millwork works well when consistency and repeatability are the priorities. Custom millwork becomes more valuable when a business needs a distinctive appearance, purpose-built functionality, or room to adapt later.
When Does Custom Millwork Make the Most Sense?
Custom millwork is often the better choice when a business wants its space to feel original and connected to its identity. As Greenfield explains, custom is ideal “when you want it to stand out and be one of one.”
That matters most in customer-facing environments such as restaurants, bars, stores, reception areas, and showrooms. Materials, colors, finishes, textures, and built-in features influence how customers experience a business. The U.S. Small Business Administration notes that carrying a distinct customer experience into a physical space can help deepen customer relationships.
Custom work also makes sense when standard products do not support employees’ actual routines. A desk, counter, cabinet, or display can be built around technology, storage, equipment, workflow, and available space rather than forcing staff to adapt to a generic layout.
When Is Modular Millwork the Smarter Option?
Modular millwork is usually practical when several rooms or locations require the same setup. Greenfield uses medical patient rooms as an example. Doctors and staff rotate between rooms, so keeping supplies, storage, and work surfaces in familiar locations supports consistency.
Research available through the National Center for Biotechnology Information supports standardization in healthcare environments. Consistent room layouts can reduce reliance on short-term memory and help people use a space more safely and efficiently.
Modular systems may also suit employee-only areas, temporary locations, franchises, or growing businesses that need repeatable installations. When specialized functions and visible branding are less important, a well-made modular solution may provide everything the business needs.
Is Custom Millwork Much More Expensive?
Custom millwork may require more engineering and planning at the beginning, but the difference between quality modular and custom work may be smaller than owners expect. Cost depends on the materials, finishes, size, complexity, and number of pieces.
The better question is what the business receives over the installation’s full life. A custom fixture that improves workflow, strengthens the brand, fits correctly, and lasts for years may offer greater value than a cheaper unit that soon requires alterations or replacement.
Greenfield emphasizes that businesses may own these environments for years, while customers and employees experience them daily. In that context, extra upfront design work can become a small part of the long-term investment.
How Can Millwork Improve Efficiency?
Well-designed millwork should make everyday tasks easier. Storage can sit where employees naturally reach for it. Technology can be incorporated into the layout, and work surfaces can be sized for specific tasks.
This supports guidance from the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, which recommends reviewing workstation designs, work practices, and production processes as part of an ergonomics program.
Efficiency may also improve business performance. When employees spend less time searching for supplies, moving around awkwardly, or working around poor layouts, they can focus more attention on productive work and customers.
Why Does Future Adaptability Matter?
Businesses should consider how quickly products, equipment, technology, or customer expectations may change. Greenfield describes a retailer that frequently replaces product displays. Instead of removing an entire wall each time, removable panels could allow faster updates with less downtime.
The U.S. General Services Administration likewise recommends adjustable and reconfigurable workplace elements that accommodate different tasks and functions.
Custom does not have to mean fixed forever. A thoughtful design can include adjustable shelves, removable panels, replaceable sections, or space for future equipment.
What Are the Hidden Costs of Choosing the Wrong System?
An inexpensive modular setup can become costly when a business outgrows it sooner than expected. The owner may need to add mismatched components, modify the original installation, or replace it entirely.
Other costs are less obvious. Poor storage, awkward work surfaces, limited adaptability, and inconsistent employee environments can affect comfort and efficiency. Greenfield recalls one business where employees preferred the custom area so strongly that the company later remodeled the older back-of-house section to match it.
Before deciding when should a business choose custom millwork, owners should evaluate daily use, repeatability, brand visibility, employee needs, future changes, and the expected lifespan of the installation.
FAQs
Is custom millwork only for customer-facing spaces?
No. It can also improve employee areas that need specialized storage, equipment placement, or workflows.
Is modular millwork always cheaper?
No. High-quality modular products may be close in price to custom work, especially after modifications.
Can custom millwork be changed later?
Yes. Designs can include removable panels, adjustable shelving, and replaceable sections.
Who benefits most from modular millwork?
Medical offices, franchises, and multi-location businesses with repeated layouts often benefit most.
How does custom millwork support branding?
It uses distinctive materials, colors, textures, and features to create a recognizable atmosphere.
What should a business consider first?
Start with how the space will be used, repeated, seen, and adapted over time.
Mike Downer: Hi, everybody. Thanks for joining me on The Maker’s Intent. I’m your host, Mike Downer, and once again, I’m joined by the very handsome Kyle Greenfield. He is the president of A.F. Johnson Millwork. How are you doing today, Kyle?
Kyle Greenfield: I’m doing great, Mike. Thanks.
Mike Downer: No worries at all. Over the last few episodes, we got into all the different aspects of retail and everything else. Today, I think we’re going to switch it up a little bit and talk about custom versus modular, and which one a business should choose.
So, when should a business choose custom millwork over modular?
Kyle Greenfield: I think there are quite a few reasons, but the basic idea is this: when you want it to stand out and be one of one, or one of just yours, and you’re trying to create your own look, then you want to go custom.
Mike Downer: That makes complete sense. So, what does the real cost difference between custom millwork and modular look like over a ten-year period?
Kyle Greenfield: Well, I guess you’d have to figure out exactly what type of modular we’re talking about. There are modular options that are very repeatable but still have a very good quality standard, compared to the cheaper options where you kind of get what you pay for.
But if we’re talking about higher-end modular with a quality finish versus custom, the cost difference really isn’t all that much. The main difference is that as something becomes highly repeatable, we don’t have to re-engineer everything. With custom, you’re going to have some engineering on the front end, but depending on the size of the piece, that might only be a few extra hours of work.
So the cost difference really isn’t going to be that much when you’re talking about creating your own brand, your own space, and your own environment. You’re going to own that for years and years, and all your customers are going to see it. I think that is definitely worth the cost difference.
Mike Downer: Agreed. It’s going to sound silly, but it’s hard to put a price on individuality.
Kyle Greenfield: Exactly.
Mike Downer: Especially if the cost isn’t bank-breaking. Quality is worth a little bit more.
Now, let’s go to the other side. There have to be some situations where modular is the smarter choice for a business. What situations would those be?
Kyle Greenfield: Absolutely. We see that a lot in medical spaces, Mike. Patient rooms are very duplicatable. If you think about how they’re used, a doctor is going to rotate between a number of rooms, so you want those rooms set up pretty much the same no matter which room the doctor goes into. That way, they are just as efficient in all of them.
Modular is definitely the way to go in that situation. You wouldn’t want those rooms to all be individual and different.
Mike Downer: That makes sense. So, let’s go to the other side of the coin again. When does investing in custom millwork make more sense than going modular?
Kyle Greenfield: There are a couple of different times I can think of. The first would be if you have a specific need. So, if we’re building something for you and you’re thinking, “I could make this modular piece work, but it would be really nice if I had a place to put all my stuff,” or “I want the computer to sit a certain way on that desk,” then custom makes sense.
When you’re going custom, we can build around how you’re going to use it. I think that functionality is really important. Going back to the first question about cost, if we can make you more efficient by building a piece around how you actually use it, it might end up being cheaper in the long run because you can make more money with it. You’re more efficient.
Mike Downer: That makes complete sense. The cost savings and the income potential are huge.
Kyle Greenfield: Correct.
Mike Downer: So, how can custom millwork help a business stand out and strengthen its brand?
Kyle Greenfield: In one of the last episodes, we talked a little bit about colors and things like that. I know we’re not necessarily talking about retail as much here, but this question ties back into building the look and feel of your business.
Whether someone walks in and the space feels warm and homey, or slick and sophisticated, it depends on the right pieces. When we’re working with you on what to pick out and how the space should feel, the colors and textures definitely matter.
The food and beverage industry is very specific about that. They are very intentional about the kind of mood they want to set, especially when they’re trying to sell big, expensive drinks and make somebody feel comfortable enough to order a couple more.
Mike Downer: Yes, sir. I’ve been a victim of that.
Kyle Greenfield: Exactly. I think we all have.
Mike Downer: Yes, sir. I’ve definitely noticed that in play.
So, why is flexibility and future adaptability important when choosing between modular and custom?
Kyle Greenfield: Well, if you know something is going to be changing quickly, Mike, we can adapt to that. I’m working with a big-box store right now, and they want the retail products they’re displaying to be changed out often. Right now, they basically have to tear the whole wall out and start again.
So we’re working with them on what happens if they don’t have to tear out the whole wall. What if we can make those panels removable? Then they can change them out as quickly as they need to.
For them, it’s about how they’re displaying and promoting certain products. That’s how they’re making their money. The quicker we can help them with that, the less downtime they have. The more products they can show off, the more money they’re going to make.
Mike Downer: That makes complete sense. So, what are the top questions that a business owner should ask before deciding between modular and custom?
Kyle Greenfield: I think it’s really just recapping what we already talked about.
First, how are they going to use it?
Second, how many places are they going to have it, and how repeatable do they want it to be? That goes back to the doctor’s office example.
Third, how much is it part of your brand? How much are you trying to create that brand?
If it’s not a customer-facing area, and it’s just your own employees in that space, you might not need something super custom. You’re not really trying to build a huge brand inside that location, so the super-custom approach might not be as important for a personal desk or back-of-house area.
Mike Downer: That makes complete sense. Great answer.
So, what is the hidden cost of outgrowing a modular setup sooner than expected?
Kyle Greenfield: I don’t know all of them off the top of my head, Mike.
Mike Downer: Just some of the hidden costs, or some of the things you’ve run across. What are some of the costs of outgrowing a modular setup when you’re trying to save money, but then you outgrow it quicker than expected? What are some of the costs that come with that?
Kyle Greenfield: Sure. The biggest one is that you’re going to have to add to it or rebuy right away. That can happen quickly.
I think more of the hidden costs go back to how you’re going to use it. We talked about that a little bit ago. How efficient can you be with it?
If you help us learn how you’re going to use it and what you’re really going to use that space for, we can make it as efficient and comfortable for you as possible. I think that can really make a difference in how you use the space, how efficient you are in the space, and how much money you can use it to make in the future.
Mike Downer: That makes complete sense.
Here’s where I always like to wind this up and see if I can get you to tell me a story. Can you share an example of a business that started out with modular and later upgraded to custom millwork, and what prompted that change?
Kyle Greenfield: That’s a great question. You threw me off on this one, so you got me today, Mike.
The area I’m thinking of was pretty custom to begin with, but they had a back-of-house area that they thought shouldn’t matter. It wasn’t a big deal. What they found was that the people who got stuck in the old area, the non-custom area, didn’t seem to have the same job satisfaction, or they were trying to get out of that area a little bit.
It worked out well for us because we had to go back in and remodel the other half, the back half, within a couple of years and make it match the other side. That part was a little bit fun, just seeing how much the employees there really enjoyed the custom side compared to the old side, as they called it.
Mike Downer: That makes complete sense. See, I didn’t throw you off. You made an example. You always do a good job with the story portion. You always come up with something good, Kyle.
Kyle Greenfield: You always make my brain work, Mike.
Mike Downer: Well, you know what? I’d rather make your brain work than mine. I’m just the guy asking the questions.
Once again, it’s been a lot of fun talking to you. I always enjoy our conversations. Maybe we’ll talk about some restaurants, engineering, or something else next time. We’ll come up with something fun.
Kyle Greenfield: Sounds good.
Mike Downer: All right. Thanks again for joining me, and we’ll talk soon.
Kyle Greenfield: All right. See you soon, Mike.
Mike Downer: Take care. Bye.
